王者DFI!LANParty创意LOGO票选活动 || DFI-ABS.OCER.net
四大品牌P45适用人群之OCER建议 | | 挑战不可能,DFI LANParty DK P45 & JR P45横测 | ASUS P6T Deluxe征服“i7”
MSI 4870X2 2GB,4850/4870 CF同门大乱斗 | | 映泰 TA790GX A2+超值登场 | | 高频不低能!威刚DDR3-1600+轻松OC2000+
OC小板典范DFI LP JR P45 | | ABS让OC更容易 DK P45 636外频达成 | | 超频网"Core i7"最亲民测试 | | GIGA X58-EXTREME抢鲜看
发新话题
打印

【转帖】[评测] XbitLabs新一轮1KW电源横向评测

【转帖】[评测] XbitLabs新一轮1KW电源横向评测

http://www.xbitlabs.com/articles/other/display/10-1kw-psu-roundup.html
引用:

Conclusion

The manufacturers are getting ever higher with their PSUs, reaching the 1500W milestone already. I still cannot grasp the purpose of such a large reserve of power – because even a very top-end gaming configuration needs only half as much at best – but 1000W power supplies have in fact become ordinary products while the manufacturers are rushing towards new goals.

Alas, not all of them reach the goals they set. There are four PSUs in this review (grouped in pairs according to the same platform) with wattage ratings much higher than 1000W, two from Tagan and two from Thermaltake, but none of them would be a very good purchase as they have high price, noisy fans, too-high output voltage ripple, and (the Thermaltake models) not very good stability of the output voltages.

The 1010W FSP Epsilon is no good, either. My earlier tests indicated that this platform was only good for 400-500W models and not higher. The Epsilon 1010 proves the point: high voltage ripple, a noisy fan, and very unstable voltages. All of this makes it impossible for me to write a positive review of it.

So if you do want a 1000W power supply, you should consider the models from Antec and Enermax as well as from Floston and Ultra Products, but I want to note that none of them has proved to be better overall than the Cooler Master Real Power Pro (tested in my previous review) that boasted stable operation at a surprisingly low (for such a high wattage) level of noise.
所以看起来,这个档位上在纹波、交叉负载、噪音、效率等测试中最终胜出的参赛选手应该是根本没有来参加比赛的Enhance代工的CoolerMaster Real Power Pro这位场外选手?
场内的胜出者应该是Enhance代工的Antec TPQ-1000吧,如果把标准放宽一点,也算上Enermax以及Andyson代工的Floston、Ultra两家电源吧。Ultra这个电源因为粗糙的内部做工还在GZ上引起了不小的争议。

最后是参赛选手一览
Antec TruePower Quattro TPQ-1000 (1000W)
Enermax Galaxy DXX EGX1000EWL (1000W)
Floston Energetix ENFP-1050W (1050W)
FSP Epsilon 1010 (1010W)
SilverPower GuardianX SP-1000E (1000W)
Tagan TG1300-U6 and Tagan ITZ1300 (1300W)
Thermaltake Toughpower W0133RE (1200W) and W0171RE (1500W)
Ultra Products X3 ULT-HE1000X (1000W)
由上到下依次是:Enhance代工、自家设计、Andyson代工、自家性能糟糕的“GreenPower改”方案、Enhance代工、Topower代工、CWT代工、Andyson代工。因为是千瓦级别,所以AcBel和SeaSonic暂时无缘这一竞技场,Enhance和Andyson在性能上笑傲群雄。

[ 本帖最后由 多米小熊 于 2008-2-1 08:39 编辑 ]
对最后一句话加个注解:
这次测试还缺了四个比较重要的选手
1、七盟,2、亿泰兴,3、Impervio,4、PC P&C
相信这四位的品质可以挑战TPQ-1000。
看這些大塊頭看得煩了,真希望他們減減肥,
Don't look at me.
Every day is so wonderful.
And suddenly,it's hard 2 breathe

回复 3# 的帖子

有减肥的啊,FSP那个Epsilion 1KW体型和标准ATX电源一边大,可是品质要逊色很多
Antec TPQ-1000这个看起来YY
目前没需要。。帮Travis顶了
引用:
原帖由 Travis 于 2008-1-22 20:57 发表
对最后一句话加个注解:
这次测试还缺了四个比较重要的选手
1、七盟,2、亿泰兴,3、Impervio,4、PC P&C
相信这四位的品质可以挑战TPQ-1000。
印象中zippy也有千瓦级别的。
新年新气象,
顶啊~~~~
Don't look at me.
Every day is so wonderful.
And suddenly,it's hard 2 breathe
发新话题